Journal Club 11/29/21: Ethics of Humanitarian Work

POCUS in Resource-Limited Settings presented by Holly A. Farkosh

POCUS, or point-of-care ultrasound, is a focused exam performed and interpreted by an examiner usually at the bedside, that must answer a specific question (is there a pleural effusion, yes or no?). The diagnosis must also be 1) relevant to consecutive treatment decision-making and 2) easily and accurately recognizable by the physician applying the US without extensive training.

There are many advantages to using POCUS in a resource-limited setting, including but not limited to: 

– Portability; relatively inexpensive starting at $2000

– Limited access to other diagnostic imaging equipment (XR, CT, MRI–all of which require additional training to read and use/operate)

– Rapid, noninvasive

– No ionizing radiation exposure

– Improves success and safety of bedside procedures

– Can easily be repeated, quickly, and without increasing radiation exposure, especially if clinical status or physical exam findings change 

– Particularly cost-effective (in the United States) in pediatric appendicitis and trauma (found to have decreased time to OR, decreased CT scans in the pediatric population, shortened length of hospital stay)

Some of the disadvantages include:

– Requirement of formal training

– Issue of how to power/charge and reliable access to this

– Handheld US requires a smartphone

– Supplies (US gel)

– Upkeep and repair

– Image portability (inability to print or save images for patients to share with other healthcare providers)

– Ethical considerations? 

Tying it all Together: Ethical Considerations for POCUS in Resource-Limited Settings

– Cost-effectiveness: some resources are deemed too expensive

– Resource limitations and differences in standard of care between the United States and other countries 

– Practitioners who may be teaching US may have limited knowledge of practicing in resource-limited settings, or there may be discrepancies in both knowledge of using the technology/resources available as well as the common presenting diseases in that region

– Sustainability: in relation to implementing training programs– what happens after instructors leave? Requires adequate planning for system integration and ongoing supervision and skill maintenance

– Limited capacity and inconsistent availability of follow-up care; screening without available treatment

Discussion Questions:

  • What other ethical considerations are there to implementing POCUS in resource-limited settings?

       – Advantage: lack of need for significant infrastructure; skills can quickly be acquired; real-time video training/support between the United States and other countries

        – Limited support for continued supervision/continual mentorship on improving skills; sustainability of training programs

        – Potential costs of training

  • What to do when you come across findings not consistent with physical exam– how to advocate for further diagnostics/evaluation?
  • Using US for central lines: lack of US availability; no formal US training; need to teach how to use US, but also important to teach things such as sterile prep/technique

Why do we have a desire to work in Global Health? By Cody Ritz

Chapter nine from Reimagining Global Health: An Introduction aims to explore a few different answers to this complex question. It’s possible that many of our desires to work in Global EM stem from some of the moral frameworks or values systems presented in these pages. The chapter lays them out as such:

Depending on your own personal motivations, you may identify with one, many, or none of these moral frameworks or value systems. This list is not meant to be exhaustive, and it barely scratches the surface of the many nuances included in each of these philosophies. While we could go to much greater lengths to wholly explore these schools of thought, I believe the greatest benefit in naming them is not solely for the purpose of categorization. Rather, by taking the time to compare these sources of motivation, we can equip ourselves with a vocabulary and mindset that helps give form to our innermost determinations. While this form develops, we can begin to understand the foundations of our own interest to work in not only global health but medicine at large. As we come to better understand ourselves, let us hope this allows us to better understand others as well.

Discussion Points:

  • With which of these frameworks/value systems do you identify personally? – One? Multiple? None of them at all? – and how has that framework informed your own perspective and approach to global health?
  • Imagine that you’re in an interview for a position you want in the future and the interviewer asks—Why do you have these interests in global health when there is already great need within your own backyard?— How do you respond? In what ways could you explain your motivations within the frameworks discussed in this chapter?

Wrap up!

As you can imagine, our mentees had a wonderful discussion surrounding these three topics! We are thrilled to be able to present a brief summary of their work here. Please stay tuned for details about our upcoming meetings.  Connect with us through one of our contact options listed below if you are interested in attending!

Thank you to our authors and presenters!

Picture of Holly Farkosh, MS4

Holly Farkosh, MS4

Marshall University School of Medicine

Picture of Cody Ritz, MS2

Cody Ritz, MS2

Drexel University College of Medicine

Keep in Touch:

[cite]

Emergency Procedures: Finger Splint

Indications

  • Fractures of distal and middle phalanx
  • Volar plate injury
  • Post reduction of dorsal PIP dislocation
  • Mallet injury (distal phalanx extensor tendon rupture with or without avulsion fracture)

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Question Of The Day #82

question of the day
35.3 - pulmonary congestion

Which of the following is the most likely cause of this patient’s condition?

Shortness of breath, also known as dyspnea, is a common reason for patients to visit the Emergency Department.  Dyspnea is often caused by a pulmonary or cardiovascular condition, but it is important to remember that dyspnea can be due to endocrine conditions, toxicologic conditions, neurologic conditions, hematologic conditions, musculoskeletal conditions, and psychiatric conditions. 

The initial approach to all patients with shortness of breath involves the primary survey, or “ABCs” (Airway, Breathing, Circulation).  This first involves checking the patient for a patent airway.  A simple method to assess the airway is to ask the patient to speak and listen for the voice.  A muffled voice, the presence of stridor, hematemesis, or a lethargic patient are clues that a patent airway may not be present.  Problems with the airway, such as an obstructing foreign body, inflammation (i.e., epiglottitis, anaphylactic shock), or vocal cord dysfunction can certainly cause shortness of breath.  Endotracheal intubation may need to be performed before moving forward.  Breathing is assessed by evaluating the function of the lungs.  Steps include looking at how the patient is breathing (fast or slow), measurement of an SpO2 level, and auscultation of both lungs for wheezing, crackles, rhonchi, or distant or absent sounds.  A low oxygen level should be immediately addressed with supplemental oxygen before moving forward.  The patient’s breathing rate and lung sounds can be very helpful in discovering the diagnosis and guiding treatment.  Lastly, circulation should be assessed.  Check the heart rate, blood pressure, peripheral pulses, skin color and temperature, and evaluate for any sites of hemorrhage.  The presence of hypotension or tachycardia should be addressed appropriately based on the presumed cause.  After the primary assessment (“ABCs”) and initial treatment actions, a more detailed history and physical exam should be conducted. 

Pertinent causes of shortness of breath for the emergency practitioner to know are outlined in the chart below. 

 

 

Select Causes of Shortness of Breath (Dyspnea)

Pulmonary

 

Tension pneumothorax, pneumonia, empyema, pleural effusion, pulmonary edema, asthma, COPD

Cardiovascular

 

Acute coronary syndrome (i.e., STEMI), pulmonary embolism, cardiac tamponade, Decompensated Congestive Heart Failure (acute pulmonary edema)

Endocrine

 

Diabetic ketoacidosis (Kussmaul breathing)

Toxicologic

 

Salicylate overdose, or any ingestion that causes a severe metabolic acidosis

Neurologic

 

Intracranial hemorrhage, Stroke, Spinal cord injury, Guillain-Barre syndrome, Myasthenia Gravis crisis (myasthenic crisis)

Hematologic

 

Severe anemia (i.e., GI bleeding, trauma, miscarriage, post-partum hemorrhage, ruptured ectopic pregnancy)

Musculoskeletal

 

Rib fracture, flail chest

Psychiatric

 

Anxiety, Panic attack

Airway Problem

Foreign body, epiglottitis, anaphylactic shock (laryngeal swelling), expanding neck hematoma

 

This patient presents to the Emergency department with 1 day of shortness of breath without chest pain, fevers, or a cough.  He has been noncompliant with his home medications for his multiple comorbid conditions.  The exam shows tachypnea, tachycardia, hypertension, a low oxygen level, pulmonary crackles, and peripheral edema.  The chest X-ray shows bilateral pulmonary congestion and infiltrates consistent with pulmonary edema.

Diabetic ketoacidosis (Choice A) can cause shortness of breath, but the severe hypertension, fluid overload on exam, and lack of hyperglycemia make DKA less likely.  Pneumonia (Choice D) can cause shortness of breath, but often has other symptoms like cough, fever, and sometimes chest pain.  It is difficult to rule out an underlying pneumonia in the presence of pulmonary edema by solely looking at the chest X-ray.  The patient’s peripheral edema, severe hypertension, and lack of cough and fever make pneumonia a less likely diagnosis responsible for that patient’s symptoms.  Myocardial infarction (Choice C) often presents with chest pain but can present with only shortness of breath.  A severe myocardial infarction with cardiogenic shock can result in acute fluid overload as seen in this patient, but hypotension would be expected.  A 12-lead EKG is required to more fully evaluate for a myocardial infarction, but the constellation of symptoms this patient has makes congestive heart failure (Choice B) the most likely diagnosis. 

Immediate initial actions for this patient should include placing the patient on a cardiac monitor, obtaining a 12-lead EKG, sitting the patient upright to assist with breathing, and providing supplemental oxygen.  Acute decompensated heart failure should be aggressively treated with Nitroglycerin to lower the blood pressure and stress on the heart (preload).  Noninvasive positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV), such as BIPAP or CPAP, is another crucial initial step to help provide oxygenation, lower the preload, and push the fluid out from the lungs.  IV diuresis to remove fluid from the body and evaluating for the underlying cause are other important steps in acute CHF management. 

References

[cite]

Emergency Procedures: Short Leg Backslab

emergency procedures-short leg backslab

Indications

  • The distal tibia and/or fibula fractures
  • Ankle injuries
  • Tarsal injuries
  • Metatarsal injuries

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Question Of The Day #81

question of the day
475.3 xray abdomen series normal chest
Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis for this patient’s condition?

Shortness of breath, also known as dyspnea, is a common reason for patients to visit the Emergency Department.  Dyspnea is often caused by a pulmonary or cardiovascular condition, but it is important to remember that dyspnea can be due to endocrine conditions, toxicologic conditions, neurologic conditions, hematologic conditions, musculoskeletal conditions, and psychiatric conditions. 

The initial approach to all patients with shortness of breath involves the primary survey, or “ABCs” (Airway, Breathing, Circulation).  This first involves checking the patient for a patent airway.  A simple method to assess the airway is to ask the patient to speak and listen for the voice.  A muffled voice, the presence of stridor, hematemesis, or a lethargic patient are clues that a patent airway may not be present.  Problems with the airway, such as an obstructing foreign body, inflammation (i.e., epiglottitis, anaphylactic shock), or vocal cord dysfunction can certainly cause shortness of breath.  Endotracheal intubation may need to be performed before moving forward.  Breathing is assessed by evaluating the function of the lungs.  Steps include looking at how the patient is breathing (fast or slow), measurement of an SpO2 level, and auscultation of both lungs for wheezing, crackles, rhonchi, or distant or absent sounds.  A low oxygen level should be immediately addressed with supplemental oxygen before moving forward.  The patient’s breathing rate and lung sounds can be very helpful in discovering the diagnosis and guiding treatment.  Lastly, circulation should be assessed.  Check the heart rate, blood pressure, peripheral pulses, skin color and temperature, and evaluate for any sites of hemorrhage.  The presence of hypotension or tachycardia should be addressed appropriately based on the presumed cause.  After the primary assessment (“ABCs”) and initial treatment actions, a more detailed history and physical exam should be conducted. 

Pertinent causes of shortness of breath for the emergency practitioner to know are outlined in the chart below. 

 

 

Select Causes of Shortness of Breath (Dyspnea)

Pulmonary

 

Tension pneumothorax, pneumonia, empyema, pleural effusion, pulmonary edema, asthma, COPD

Cardiovascular

 

Acute coronary syndrome (i.e., STEMI), pulmonary embolism, cardiac tamponade, Decompensated Congestive Heart Failure (acute pulmonary edema)

Endocrine

 

Diabetic ketoacidosis (Kussmaul breathing)

Toxicologic

 

Salicylate overdose, or any ingestion that causes a severe metabolic acidosis

Neurologic

 

Intracranial hemorrhage, Stroke, Spinal cord injury, Guillain-Barre syndrome, Myasthenia Gravis crisis (myasthenic crisis)

Hematologic

 

Severe anemia (i.e., GI bleeding, trauma, miscarriage, post-partum hemorrhage, ruptured ectopic pregnancy)

Musculoskeletal

 

Rib fracture, flail chest

Psychiatric

 

Anxiety, Panic attack

Airway Problem

Foreign body, epiglottitis, anaphylactic shock (laryngeal swelling), expanding neck hematoma

This patient presents to the Emergency Department with 1 day of acute onset shortness of breath with pleuritic chest pain. Her exam shows tachycardia, tachypnea, a normal glucose level, and clear lungs bilaterally.  The chest X-ray provided shows no acute abnormalities.  Pneumothorax (Choice A) can present as acute onset shortness of breath with pleuritic chest pain, but the chest X-ray shows no signs of pneumothorax.  Diabetic Ketoacidosis (Choice B) can cause shortness of breath, and this patient has a history of diabetes.  However, the patient lacks other symptoms of this condition such as hyperglycemia (often glucose >250mg/dL (13.8mmol/L)), polydipsia, polyphagia, polyuria, or vomiting.  This makes DKA an unlikely diagnosis. Pneumonia (Choice D) is also unlikely as there is no fever, no cough, and no infiltrate seen on the chest X-ray provided.  Pulmonary Embolism (Choice C) is the most likely diagnosis and the correct answer.

The most common presenting symptom in pulmonary embolism (PE) is shortness of breath.  Other symptoms seen in PE include chest pain worsened by deep inspiration, unilateral leg swelling, hemoptysis, and fever.  Risk factors for PE include immobility, recent surgery or hospitalization, trauma, or hypercoagulable states (malignancy, estrogen use, Factor V Leiden mutation, antiphospholipid syndrome).  Common signs of PE on physical examination include tachycardia (common), fever (less common), and sometimes hypotension in a massive PE causing obstructive shock.  The gold standard for PE diagnosis is CT pulmonary angiography, but D-dimer blood testing, bedside ultrasound, and other tests can be useful in PE diagnosis.  The mainstay of treatment in PE is anticoagulation.  Unfractionated heparin and low molecular weight heparin are equally effective in PE.  Surgical treatment (embolectomy) and thrombolysis (alteplase) are other treatment options fo larger PEs.

References

[cite]

Emergency Procedures: Long Leg Backslab

emergency procedures-long leg backslab

Indications

  • Tibia and/or fibula shaft fractures
  • Knee and patellar fractures
  • Distal femur fractures

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Emergency Procedures: Volar Short Arm Slab

emergency procedures-volar short arm slab

Indications

  • Soft tissue injuries to hand and wrist
  • Carpal bone fractures (excluding scaphoid/trapezium)
  • Buckle fractures of the distal radius

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Question Of The Day #80

question of the day
753 - bradycardia
Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management for this patient’s condition?  

This patient presents to the Emergency department with generalized weakness and dizziness after accidently ingesting extra diltiazem tablets 1.5 hours prior to arrival.  The exam shows bradycardia, hypotension, an elevated glucose level, and a patient without altered mental status.  The EKG shows sinus bradycardia without any conduction blocks.

This patient’s clinical presentation is likely due to diltiazem overdose.  Diltiazem is a calcium channel blocker. Calcium channel blocker medications are categorized as the dihydropyridines (nifedipine, amlodipine, nicardipine) and the non-dihydropyridines (verapamil, diltiazem).  The dihydropyridines (DHPs) cause systemic vasodilation, hypotension, and often a reflex tachycardia in overdose.  The non-DHPs act more directly on the heart with less peripheral effects and cause hypotension and bradycardia.  Calcium channel blocker overdose can mimic beta blocker overdose as both medication classes have similar effects on the body. 

The initial management of any patient who has ingested a potentially dangerous medication is the “ABCs”, also known as the primary survey.  This includes assessment and management of the airway (i.e., intubation for somnolence and aspiration risk), breathing (i.e., supplemental oxygen for hypoxia), and circulation (i.e., IV fluids, vasopressors for hypotension).  Decontamination is another consideration depending on the agent the patient has been exposed to.  An EKG should be ordered early in all toxic ingestions to evaluate for signs of cardiac toxicity, such as a prolonged QT interval or prolonged QRS interval.  Checking for other dangerous coingestants, like serum levels of salicylates and paracetamol (APAP) should be routinely done.  Specific toxic effects seen in calcium channel blocker and beta blocker overdose are outlined in the chart below.

IV Glucagon (Choice A) is useful as an adjunctive treatment in both calcium channel blocker and beta blocker overdose.  However, glucagon often causes vomiting and is not a first-line agent.  IV fluids, atropine, vasopressors, and activated charcoal should be attempted before glucagon.  Antiemetics should be considered prior to IV Glucagon administration given its side effect of nausea and vomiting.  Transvenous pacing (Choice C) and IV Calcium gluconate (Choice D) are also considered second-line treatments to try when the patient is not responding to IV fluids, atropine, or vasopressors.  The best next step in this case is to administer IV Fluids (Choice B). 

References

[cite]

Emergency Procedures: Long Arm Backslab

emergency procedures-long arm backslab

Indications

  • Acute management of elbow region injuries such as radial head fractures, distal humerus fractures, after reductions of elbow dislocations; 
  • Proximal and mid-forearm, and wrist injuries such as Colles or Smith fractures;
  • Acute management of distal radial (nonbuckle) and/or ulnar fractures in children.

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Question Of The Day #79

question of the day
Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?

This patient arrives to the Emergency department with altered mental status and hypotension after ingestion of multiple pills at home.  On exam, she is hypotensive, tachycardic, confused, and has dilated pupils with dry skin.  The patient has most likely ingested amitriptyline tablets given the history provided in the question.  Amitriptyline is a tricyclic antidepressant medication.  Despite the clear history, it is very important to check levels for possible other coingestants, like paracetamol (APAP) and salicylates.

Tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs) impact many different receptors in the body, so the clinical presentation of a patient with TCA overdose can vary considerably.  Important features to remember are cardiovascular toxicity with a widened QRS and hypotension, as well as an anticholinergic toxidrome.  A 12-lead EKG should be ordered early in any case of possible overdose, and an EKG in TCA overdose is a crucial step in evaluation.  Supportive care and IV sodium bicarbonate are the mainstays of treatment for TCA overdose.  See the table below for details regarding the clinical features and treatment of these patients. 

Toxic effects of Tricyclic Antidepressant (TCA) overdose

Clinical Features

Treatment

Na-channel blockade

Cardiac arrythmias,

Wide QRS (>100msec), Prominent R wave in AvR (>3mm)

IV Sodium Bicarbonate100mEq (1-2mEq/kg),

 

Titrate to QRS <100 and/or improved hypotension

Alpha-1 adrenergic receptor blockade

Hypotension

IVF, vasopressors

Serotonin reuptake blockade

Seizures

Benzodiazepines

Muscarinic- Ach receptor blockade (Anticholinergic)

Anticholinergic toxidrome– altered mental status, delirium, hyperthermia, tachycardia, hypertension, dilated pupils, dry skin

Benzodiazepines, supportive care.

 

Avoid Physostigmine.

Histamine receptor (H1) blockade

Drowsiness, coma

Supportive care

IV Physostigmine (Choice A) can be used to treat an anticholinergic toxidrome along with supportive care and benzodiazepines.  This patient does appear to have an anticholinergic toxidrome, but there is a high suspicion for TCA overdose.  Physostigmine should be avoided in TCA overdose due to data indicating worse outcomes in TCA overdose patients who receive physostigmine.  IV Norepinephrine (Choice B) may eventually be required to manage this patient’s hypotension.  However, IV fluids and sodium bicarbonate to reverse the cardiac toxicity should be used first.  IV Metoprolol (Choice D) may help relieve the tachycardia, but it would worsen the patient’s hypotension and shock state.   The best next step is IV Sodium bicarbonate (Choice C), which is the treatment for TCA overdose.  Sodium bicarbonate prevents TCA binding to cardiac sodium channels, thereby stabilizing the heart and preventing cardiac dysrhythmias and death. Sodium bicarbonate is given as an infusion until the QRS interval shortens <100msec and the hypotension improves. 

References

[cite]

Emergency Procedures: Thumb Spica Splint

emergency procedures-thumb spica splint

Indications

  • Injuries to scaphoid/trapezium
  • Nondisplaced, nonangulated, extra-articular first metacarpal fractures
  • Stable thumb fractures with or without closed reduction

This video has been provided by Emergency Procedures App developers (Dr John Mackenzie and Dr James Miers) in order to help medical students, interns in training. Please visit the video source or Emergency Procedures app for more procedure videos and information. 

Contributors

Picture of Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie

Dr John Mackenzie MBChB , Dip MSM, FACEM . Staff Specialist Emergency Medicine, Consultant Hyperbaric Medicine Specialist, at Prince of Wales Hospital. Known for cycling endlessly for no apparent reason. 20 years of developing virtual learning for clinicians at all levels.

Picture of Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers

Dr James Miers BSc BMBS (Hons) FACEM, Staff Specialist in Emergency Medicine, Prince of Wales Hospital, Sydney. Passion for gypsy jazz and chess. Lead author of Lead author of Emergency Procedures App.

Further Reading

Question Of The Day #78

question of the day
Which of the following is the most likely cause for this patient’s condition?

This patient presents to the Emergency department from a party with slurred speech and somnolence after drinking homemade alcohol.  On exam, his vital signs and glucose are normal, he is nonresponsive to pain, and he has a GCS of 3 (normal GCS is 15).  He is intubated due to his inability to protect his airway and risk for aspiration.  Intubation is an important first step in managing this patient.

Altered mental status has a broad differential diagnosis, including intracranial bleeding, stroke, post-ictal state, hypoglycemia, electrolyte abnormalities, other metabolic causes, infectious etiologies, toxicological causes, and many other conditions.  The immediate evaluation and treatment of this patient should focus on the ‘ABCs’, or any abnormality in the airway, breathing, and circulation.  Any rapidly correctable causes of altered mental status, like hypoxia, hypoglycemia, or hyperthermia, should be addressed appropriately at this stage (i.e., supplemental oxygen, intubation, IV dextrose, body cooling). 

Paracetamol (APAP) overdose (Choice A) is often accompanied with little to no symptoms in the first 24hours.  Later in the ingestion timeline, liver failure and its associated sequalae can occur if no antidote is given.  The symptoms exhibited by the patient do not correlate with APAP overdose.  Opioid overdose (Choice D) can cause severely depressed mental status as seen in this patient.  However, opioid overdose also has decreased respiratory rate, pinpoint pupils, and sometimes associated bradycardia or hypotension.  This patient has normal vital signs and normal pupil size.  This patient ingested some type of alcohol at the party, but it is unclear if it is ethanol or a toxic alcohol (i.e., methanol, ethylene glycol).  Both ethanol and methanol ingestion (Choice B) can cause similar exam findings of depressed mental status as in this patient.  Other features of toxic alcohol ingestion include vision changes (methanol), hemorrhagic gastritis (isopropyl alcohol), coma, seizures, and hyperventilation (respiratory compensation for severe acidosis).  Ethanol and many of the toxic alcohols will cause an increased anion gap metabolic acidosis with an increased osmolar gap.  Helpful tests to differentiate ethanol from a toxic alcohol are serum levels of ethanol and serum toxic alcohol levels (if available).  A somnolent, intoxicated-appearing patient with a negative ethanol level should raise suspicion for toxic alcohol poisoning.  Urine studies may also show oxalate crystals in ethylene glycol ingestion. 

Since ethanol is not a listed choice and laboratory studies are not provided, methanol ingestion (Choice B) is the most likely cause of this patient’s symptoms.  Fomepizole (Choice C) is an intravenous medication that inhibits the alcohol dehydrogenase enzyme.  Fomepizole is the antidote to toxic alcohols by slowing the production of dangerous toxic alcohol metabolites.  The correct answer is Choice B.

References

[cite]